A short catalog of some tribulations of all those involved in the art of music:
The abstract nature of the art. It is hard to own or sell something that exists only as a transient vibration, easily taken by all.
When societies decided to protect musical artworks, they made sure as well to take it for themselves. They said to the artists: "those objects aren't really yours, they are ours, you may have them for a moment and then we will take them back." (see Lou Harrison's Music Primer)
Even after giving those small protections, many societies stole anyway. The USA freely appropriated the music and art of others before the late 19th century, even well into the 20th (see Gilbert and Sullivan, Stravinsky, etc). And there is the motivic/musical stealing from the trad classical composers to John Zorn (unfortunately not related to Max Zorn even though, well, his Lemma).
Reproduction was the biggest disaster to befall music. Before recording - player pianos and their magnetic ilk - all music was live music. If you wished to hear it, you played it or sang it or others did in your presence, from a tenor in your local pub to drummers in West Africa. Live music dropped from this 100% to something like 4% in the IFPI's study Engaging With Music 2023. not only killing opportunities for performers, but fundamentally changing the idea of what music is.
Even live music is often no longer produced at the time of performance given sequencing, prerecorded backing tracks and vocals, plus the desire for the audience to hear it as the object they remember. Cage in 1983 said that recordings destroy the need for and distort the true function of real music, replacing it with an artificial substitute. The "aura" of a work, as in Walter Benjamin's Kunstwerk im Zeitalter seiner technischen Reproduzierbarkeit, withers away in reproduction, shifting from an object of reverence to a consumable.
Some will say that recording also expanded opportunities, created the oft-mentioned recording studio as an instrument, and even Cage used it as such in Indeterminacy, not to mention Imaginary Landscape No. 5 (1952, for 42 phonograph records) or the Williams Mix. All true, and the remaining shell of music is all around us.
Some might also say that recording allowed the creation of types of music that could never have existed before, from musique concrète to multitracking to highly produced works in every genre. I remember the engineers who created the first digital audio editors (I had friends at Sonic Solutions) were surprised to find that classical musicians leapt to use them, eager to edit every millisecond of every performance in pursuit of some kind of perfection.
Sampling was feared to be the death of performance - and it was. Instrumentalists arrived at a recording session only to find a score consisting of a catalog of pitches, trills, effects, tremolos, dynamics and attacks - centuries of performance practice, years of human practice, reduced to a poor simulacrum. Synthesis - something I worked on at Yamaha - was meant to do this as well, but sampling was easier.
Sampling isn't just notes, it is passages. I remember in one section of Sub Pontio Pilato, during a performance, noticing the sound person recording something, and he calmly explained that he liked the chord progression. I suppose he liked not only the chord progression, but the orchestration etc, and I assume he planned to use it for his own art. Well, we all steal, and I have one of the surviving copies of John Oswald's Plunderphonics.
Then they came for performance - the LinnDrum in the 1980s and more so the TR-808 was the first time I was aware of a commercial box that could replace a player completely. Poorly, some said, but the flip side is that drum machines germinated new styles on its machine-gun-like exactitude, EDM being the prime example, as well as later hip-hop.
As the technology progressed, whole works became very simply stealable by anyone. At the end of the last century, MP3 encoding and the internet especially allowed individuals to slurp up all popular music and eventually every piece of music ever recorded, all of which was institutionalized in the streaming services of today.
We are now in the latest hoovering-up, this time to feed the ravenous maw of the diffusion models. Some try to be "ethical" in a self-defined way, or have been legally required to negotiate licenses.
Diffusion models are just the latest in a long series of algorithmic musical developments. We had Markov chains trained on music in the 1950s, e.g. Olson and Belar (1955, Stephen Foster tunes), Pinkerton (1956, nursery tunes), and Hiller and Isaacson's
Illiac Suite(1957), and in commercial products also of the 1980s like Zicarelli's Jam Factory. David Cope's
Experiments in Musical Intelligence which was "AI" in the olden sense, looking for patterns in a large corpus of mostly classical works already in the public domain (aka stolen by society - see above).
The poverty of these early models was interesting, much as the original Dall-E image models were more artistically interesting than the endless AI internet ads of fake old people selling real leather shoes. But the scale is different, and the enormous amounts of money, and the spread of the models to everyone. One could say this is a good thing, a return to the past, the modern equivalent of the piano that was in every home. Democratization sounds like a good thing maybe, and I think music should be part of everyone's life in whatever way it can be, but I would be saddened by the loss of the revered artist who crafts something over years.
This takes us to displacement, another step in the above abbreviated lists of travesties. Every one of the changes above have hurt real people, while opening up opportunities and money for others. Not necessarily for the artists, as they often are given the least, but rather the large media and technology organizations. Like the scorpion, that is their nature: "work for hire", abusive contracts in the recording industry, outright theft. We live in a world where ok-ness is equated with get-away-with-ness.
But the truth is that you can't stop it. Musicians leap to every new technology and use it. Recorded music has less and less relationship to what music was before it, nor electronic music to what was before it, nor sampled instruments, nor house music, and so on. I understand the neural-net-model companies gobbled up the entire internet, but these are just societal choices: we can say no, but we never do. And remember that we fundamentally steal everyone's works into the public domain.
The laws of copyright are hacks built on hacks. For example, you can't use a recording without permission, but you can make and sell your own recording of a composition once it has been recorded. That's just history and law. Is it ethical? I dunno, but it created a thriving world of cover songs and versions. Maybe that was the intention, but since it came out of fear that the Aeolian Company was cornering piano-roll rights (1908-1909 ish), probably not. But you can't use your recording in a video without an explicit license. It's all just what we want, or maybe don't want, but we get anyway.
All of this has impinged on my paid life. Much of what I do day-to-day is grease the wheels of copyright, licensing, royalty payments, contracts between media companies and technology companies. Many of them are customers of ours. All this comes up in conversation with colleagues, as well as with artists in my artist's life. What spurred me to commit pen to paper was Joshua Kosman's Slopera, more about the visual ai slop, but it belongs to a conversation that is the background buzz of my life.